It’s almost too easy to get the complete works of H.P Lovecraft. Barnes and Noble, just for example, sells a handsome single-volume complete edition of his work (all 1112 pages!) for just $18. So why on earth would you ever want to spend your time and money collecting vintage paperbacks containing only a fraction of his complete works?

I made a half-hearted attempt to answer that question in the first article of this series, Collecting Lovecraft. Collecting is an emotional hobby, not a rational one, so trying to fathom the collecting urge purely on a rational basis is only going to get you so far. In truth, it usually boils down to something as simple as fondness for cover art, or nostalgia for the particular edition that first introduced you to an author.

Above you can see a colorful assortment of Lancer and Ballantine paperback editions of H.P. Lovecraft originally published between 1967 and 1973: The Colour Out of Space (1967), Tales of the Cthulhu Mythos, Volume 2, edited by August Derleth (1969), The Shuttered Room and Other Tales of Horror, by Lovecraft and Derleth (1973), The Survivor and Others by Lovecraft and Derleth (1971), and The Spawn of Cthulhu, edited by Lin Carter (1971). Truthfully, I’m not too fond of these covers, and they don’t hold any particular nostalgia for me — they were all out of print long before I discovered Lovecraft. So why was I so determined to buy them?

Back in August the New York Times published a fascinating article about Zero Freitas, the Brazilian millionaire collecting every vinyl record ever made. I don’t mean one copy of every record, I mean every single piece of vinyl with music on it in the world. He’s amassed millions so far. I distinctly remember the first time I read the piece, I nodded along and thought, “Yeah, I get it.”

When I saw the collection above on eBay in early August, it was selling for under $24, or about $4.75 per book. I remember thinking, “I don’t want these all that much. But I want them more than that.” So I bought them.

I’m not going to try and explain the particular psychosis of collecting here (not sure I could). But there is a process of rationalization that goes along with every purchase, a method of explaining to yourself why you need that particular book. It won’t explain the collecting impulse to you, but it may help you understand what it’s like to live with a collector.

What’s interesting about these editions isn’t the cover art (although even that’s intriguing in a way, if you’re a student of the way horror has been marketed down through the decades). It’s the fact that most contain stories not included in the modern complete editions.

Have a look at The Shuttered Room, for example (at left, with the creepy and distinctive John Holmes cover art). The title story is one of Lovecraft’s more renowned stories, and was even made into a 1967 British horror movie starring Gig Young and Carol Lynley. But you won’t find it in the massive collected edition I mentioned above.

Why? Because it was mostly written by August Derleth, based on nothing more than a few lines left behind by Lovecraft when he died.

Derleth, who called himself Lovecraft’s “posthumous collaborator,” produced several volumes of fiction based on fragments left behind by Lovecraft. The Shuttered Room contains six short stories; the title story, plus “Witches’ Hollow,” “The Horror from the Middle Span,” “The Shadow in the Attic,” “The Fisherman of Falcon Point” and “The Dark Brotherhood.”

The film version of The Shuttered Room (also released under the title Blood Island) was directed by David Greene. It follows a couple who move into a house with dark secrets, and doesn’t appear to be part of the wider Cthulhu Mythos. I haven’t seen it, but if I can find a copy I may have to change that.

The Survivor and Others is another Derleth collection of Lovecraft pastiches/collaborations. It contains seven different stories, with this admittedly intriguing book blurb on the back:

Seven magnificent tales in which Great Cthulhu walks again, the Dunwich-Arkham country lives once more, and, in a final allegory, Lovecraft himself is portrayed in a quasi-autobiographical manner. The last, rare stories of a master craftsman.

Here’s a capture of the complete wrap-around cover, probably the best of the lot:

If you’re not a Derleth fan, then the two books in this set of most interest to you will be the two anthologies, Tales of the Cthulhu Mythos, Volume 2, edited by August Derleth, from 1969, and The Spawn of Cthulhu, edited by Lin Carter (1971). Both contain a fine assortment of Lovecraft-inspired fiction from a wide range of authors.

Tales of the Cthulhu Mythos, Volume 2 is the second half of a two-volume paperback reprint of the 1969 Arkham House hard cover collection at right, which assembled a mix of Weird Tales reprints and original fiction. Here’s the book blurb for the paperback edition:

The Legend of Cthulhu grew from the stories of H.P.Lovecraft, with the concept of a host of malign entities from beyond the barriers of time and space and their abominable links to certain degenerate humans. Fascinated by Lovecraft’s eerie creation, other writers — such as August Derleth, Robert Bloch, Frank Belknap Long, and Colin Wilson — added new stories to this fantastic cycle. In addition to Lovecrafts classic “The Haunter of the Dark” this volume includes stories by Robert Bloch, Colin Wilson, and others.

H.P. Lovecraft. This Century’s greatest master of weird fantasy — creator of an eldritch dimension of horror, swarming with such entities as dread Cthulhu, Yog-Sothoth, Hastur, lurkers in the earth or beyond the barriers of time.

And here’s the Table of Contents, with four Weird Tales reprints and five stories from 1969, including Ramsey Campbell’s famous “Cold Print,” and a novella by Colin Wilson:

“The Shambler from the Stars” by Robert Bloch (Weird Tales, September 1935)
“The Haunter of the Dark” by H. P. Lovecraft (Weird Tales, December 1936)
“The Shadow from the Steeple” by Robert Bloch (Weird Tales, September 1950)
“Notebook Found in a Deserted House” by Robert Bloch (Weird Tales, May 1951)
“Cold Print” by Ramsey Campbell (Tales of the Cthulhu Mythos, 1969)
“The Sister City” by Brian Lumley (Tales of the Cthulhu Mythos, 1969)
“Cement Surroundings” by Brian Lumley (Tales of the Cthulhu Mythos, 1969)
“The Deep Ones” by James Wade (Tales of the Cthulhu Mythos, 1969)
“The Return of the Lloigor” by Colin Wilson (Tales of the Cthulhu Mythos, 1969)
Biographical Notes

Lin Carter’s The Spawn of Cthulhu is the companion volume to his non-fiction book H.P. Lovecraft: A Look Behind the Cthulhu Mythos (discussed last time). Here it is again, in case you forgot.

The Spawn of Cthulhu is a terrific assortment, with stories by Robert E. Howard, Clark Ashton Smith, Frank Belknap Long, August Derleth, Ambrose Bierce, Robert W. Chambers and others, plus poems by Vincent Starrett, Lin Carter, and Walter C. DeBill, Jr.

Introduction: About The Spawn of Cthulhu and H. P. Lovecraft by Lin Carter
“The Whisperer in Darkness” by H. P. Lovecraft (Weird Tales, August 1931)
“An Inhabitant of Carcosa” by Ambrose Bierce (Tales of Soldiers and Civilians, 1891)
“The Yellow Sign” by Robert W. Chambers (The King in Yellow, 1895)
“Cordelia’s Song: From the King in Yellow” by Vincent Starrett (Weird Tales, April 1938) — poem
“The Return of Hastur” by August Derleth (Weird Tales, March 1939)
“Litany to Hastur” by Lin Carter (1965) — poem
“The Children of the Night” by Robert E. Howard (Weird Tales, April-May 1931)
“K’n-yan” by Walter C. DeBill, Jr. (The Arkham Collector, Winter 1971) — poem
“The Tale of Satampra Zeiros” by Clark Ashton Smith (Weird Tales, November 1931)
“The Hounds of Tindalos” by Frank Belknap Long (Weird Tales, March 1929)
“The Curse of Yig” by H. P. Lovecraft and Zealia Bishop (Weird Tales, November 1929)
“The Mine on Yuggoth” by Ramsey Campbell (The Inhabitant of the Lake and Less Welcome Tenants, 1964)

Read Keith West’s detailed review here.

Finally, we have the last book in the set, the 1967 Lancer edition of The Colour Out of Space and Others. It’s exactly identical to the 1978 Jove edition, which I covered here (minus the Rowena cover, and if you ignore the fact the stories are in a slightly different order.)

So there you have it. Why do I collect vintage paperbacks? Because if you have the complete works of H.P. Lovecraft in a modern hardcover edition, you’re very likely to ignore the earlier editions… and in the process overlook a whole wealth of splendid fiction, art, and literary history. Buying the complete edition is lazy.

But you should also consider the Barnes and Noble hardcover. It’s great.

The Collecting Lovecraft series far consists of:

Collecting Lovecraft, Part I
Collecting Lovecraft, Part II
Collecting Lovecraft, Part III: The Arkham Hardcovers

See all of our Vintage Treasure posts here.

Next time, we’ll look at the The Arkham Hardcover editions of Lovecraft, and why you want them all. See you then.