The Public Life of Sherlock Holmes: The Scarlet Claw

The Public Life of Sherlock Holmes: The Scarlet Claw

rathbone_clawposterWe’re back with more Basil Rathbone again this week. Of course, you read last week’s essay about Sherlock Holmes & the Secret Weapon. This week, it’s a look at The Scarlet Claw, which seems to be considered the best of the Universal films (though it’s not my favorite).

First, let me mention the restorations done for the Rathbone films. The UCLA Film and Television Archive has restored over 700 movies and television shows, including all 14 of the Rathbone/Bruce films. I had bad VHS copies of this series and UCLA did a phenomenal job in restoring them. They are a treat to watch.

They also include commentary tracks – some by Holmes author and expert (and my former editor) David Stuart Davies. These DVDs have become more affordable over the years and I highly recommend purchasing these over cheaper, much lower quality discs. Trust me. I used to run the website, you know!

Moving on: We can divide Basil Rathbone’s movie career as Holmes into three phases. The first encompasses the two films from Twentieth Century Fox: The Hound of the Baskervilles and The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes. Both of these were set in Victorian England and Rathbone dons the deerstalker and Inverness cape.

Next are the first three Universal films. In Sherlock Holmes & the Voice of Terror, SH & the Secret Weapon and SH in Washington, the great detective is aiding the war effort. These three are more patriotic spy flicks than typical Holmes fare.

Finally, we have the remaining nine Universal films in which Holmes is back to just being a detective – albeit in what was then modern times: the forties. The quality of the scripts varied, but the non-war movies have definitely aged better and are more suited for repeat viewings.

rathbone_clawskepticsScarlet Claw is the sixth Universal Holmes film and Rathbone’s eighth as the great detective. It was originally to be called Sherlock Holmes vs. Moriarty. However, when the professor was dropped from the script, it became Sherlock Holmes in Canada. Finally, The Scarlet Claw stuck.

Holmes and Watson are in Quebec, Canada, as skeptics at a convention of the occult. While there, Lord Penrose, a believer, is told that his wife has been murdered in their nearby village of La Mort Rouge. Her throat has been torn out, furthering rumors that a monster is on the loose. She had sent Holmes a letter that he received just after news of her death, saying that she felt she was in danger (perceptive woman). Holmes and Watson head off to try and solve the case.

Many members of the cast appeared in other films in the series. The patrician Paul Cavanagh (Lord Penrose) was also in The House of Fear and The Woman in Green. Ian Wolfe (Drake) appeared in SH In Washington and The Pearl of Death. Arthur Hohl (Emile) had been previously seen in The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes. Gerald Hamer (Potts) was all over the series, acting in SH In Washington, SH Faces Death, Pursuit to Algiers and Terror By Night.  And Miles Mander (Judge Brisson) not only popped up in The Pearl of Death, but he was also in Arthur Wontner’s lost film, The Missing Rembrandt.

Bruce’s Watson is clueless, as usual. He has no idea that Holmes is using him as a distraction while the detective is off working on the case. The doctor blusters his way along while Holmes is in crime-solving mode.

rathbone_clawbruceWatson, drunk, references a G.K. Chesterton Father Brown story that actually mirrors what’s going on, but he totally misses the connection. He rushes off to “save” Holmes in the swamp and of course, completely makes a hash of it. And Watson falling down the stairs when he comes to assist Holmes in the abandoned hotel is just more of him being a buffoon. As usual, I find myself wondering why Holmes saddles himself with this dead weight assistant.

Rathbone is typically fine as Holmes. He just looks and sounds like the great detective should. Unfortunately, in nailing the part as he did, Rathbone grew tired of Holmes and quit the films and radio shows when his contract expired (causing a temporary rift with Bruce), In his autobiography he said,

“The continuous repetition [of the role] left me virtually repeating myself every time in a character I had already conceived and developed. The stories varied but I was always the same character merely repeating myself…”

I wouldn’t say this was one of Holmes’ greatest successes, as after he identifies the murder weapon, three people are killed before he stops the villain.

The Hound of the Baskerville & “The Sussex Vampire” are mentioned by Watson, who is rambling and is cut off by Holmes. There are a couple of elements in the film that draw on The Hound, such as Holmes stalking the killer in the foggy swamp.

The Scarlet Claw is a horror movie at heart, and the black and white photography (always solid in the series) contributes to the mood.

The movie finishes with Holmes delivering a sincere tribute to Canada, quoting Winston Churchill:

“Canada, the lynchpin of the English-speaking world, whose relations with the United States on the one hand, and the British Commonwealth and the Motherland on the other. Canada, the link that joins together these great branches of the human family.”

Something to remember when watching these Rathbone/Bruce movies is that they were B picture. They were made quickly and cheaply. Scarlet Claw was just one of three in the series released in 1944. The quality of the acting and the cinematography in these Holmes movies was quite good for the class. They hold up better than most B pictures cranked out during the era and are much more like A releases.

I’d guess that the next Rathbone post will tackle one of the Fox movies.

Prior posts related to Holmes on screen:

1900-1920 Holmes’ Before Eille Norwood
1914 James Bragington – A Study in Scarlet
1916 William Gillette – Sherlock Holmes
1921-1923 Eille Norwood – Stoll Pictures
1922 John Barrymore – Sherlock Holmes
1931 Raymond Massey – The Speckled Band
1931-1937 Arthur Wontner – Five Films
1933 Reginald Owens – A Study in Scarlet
1939 – 1946  Basil Rathbone – The Secret Weapon
1949/1951  Alan Napier & Alan Wheatley – Alans on TV
1954 -1955 Ronald Howard – The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes
1959 Peter Cushing – Hammer’s Hound of the Baskervilles
1979 Christopher Plummer – Murder By Decree
1982 Tom Baker – The Hound of the Baskervilles
1983 Ian Richardson – The Hound of the Baskervilles & The Sign of Four
1983 Peter O’Toole – The Animated Novels
1984-1985 Jeremy Brett – The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes (Parts One, Two and Three)
1991-1992 Christopher Lee – The Golden Years
2010-2017 Benedict Cumberbatch – Sherlock (Post OnePost Two, Post Three and Post Four)
2012 – 2016 Johnny Lee Miller – Elementary (Post One and Post Two)
Watson Through the Years – Comic Relief?

You can read Bob Byrne’s ‘The Public Life of Sherlock Holmes’ column here at Black Gate every Monday morning.

He founded, the only website dedicated to the ‘Sherlock Holmes of Praed Street’ and blogs about Holmes and other mystery matters at Almost Holmes.

He has contributed stories to The MX Book of New Sherlock Holmes Stories – Parts III, IV and V.

Notify of

Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
R.K. Robinson

I agree the UCLA Film School did an excellent job with the remastering, those DVDs are well worth the reasonable cost.

Scarlet Claw has long been a favorite of mine since I first saw it on late television in the late 1960s. I know it’s not the “best”, but it’s very entertaining, and I’ve watched it many times.

Rob T.

“I know it’s not the “’best’”

Most fans and critics do consider *The Scarlet Claw* the best of the Universal series, and rightly so.

Eugene R.

So, Rathbone grew tired of portraying Holmes once he had mastered the character? Not surprising.

But Bruce wanted to continue the buffoonery? Did he ever express his thoughts and feelings about the rather cartoonish Watson he was playing?

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x